Login

Cracker Barrel scraps its rebranding. Here are attempts by other firms that also didn't last.

National restaurant chain switches back to its original look after criticism
Cracker Barrel is going back to its original logo, above, after a more streamlined look drew criticism. (Getty Images)
Cracker Barrel is going back to its original logo, above, after a more streamlined look drew criticism. (Getty Images)
CoStar News
August 27, 2025 | 8:14 P.M.

Country-themed restaurant chain Cracker Barrel wasted little time reversing course after its new branding drew criticism from some customers, social media posters and even President Donald Trump. In doing so, it becomes just the latest company to scrap an attempt to remake its image.

On Aug. 19, Cracker Barrel said it would replace its gold-and-brown logo featuring a man leaning against a barrel with a simplified version of the chain's name. The reaction was swift, especially online, where thousands offered opinions. Some were negative, like Trump saying on his social media channel that the chain "should go back to the old logo."

On Tuesday, Cracker Barrel said that after hearing the concern, it would abandon that plan. "Our new logo is going away and our 'Old Timer' will remain," the Lebanon, Tennessee–based company said on Facebook.

The move by the chain, which operates almost 660 Cracker Barrel locations in 44 states, shows that rebranding can be harder than it looks.

This was Cracker Barrel's rebranded, and quickly scrapped, logo. (Cracker Barrel)
This was Cracker Barrel's rebranded, and quickly scrapped, logo. (Cracker Barrel)

"The goal is always to create a functional and flexible brand system that resonates with internal and external audiences," Jae Robbins, president at Atlanta-based real estate marketing and design firm Resource Branding, said in an email to CoStar News.

But that isn't always easy. As Tim Calkins, a marketing professor at Northwestern University, put it on LinkedIn: "The challenge for a brand is to be relevant and change without losing too many of its fans."

Here are some other companies that scrapped their rebranding efforts.

The Gap

The clothing retail chain Gap ditched a new logo in 2010 after about a week. It followed backlash from consumers, who had formed an emotional attachment to the products, deciding the new lettering was too bland, the BBC reported.

Low angle view of Gap store and billboards, Times Square, New York City, New York. (Photo by: GHI Plexi Images/UCG/Universal Images Group via Getty Images) (UCG/Universal Images Group via G)
After an attempt at a new Gap logo failed, the retailer reverted to this familiar branding. (Gap)

WeWork

In early 2019, coworking giant WeWork's attempt to remake itself as the We Co. drew criticism online. The company reverted to the more focused and descriptive WeWork in October 2020.

Signage for shared office giant WeWork is seen outside a building in Seoul on November 7, 2023. Beleaguered shared office giant WeWork, which has been in dire financial straits for years, announced on November 6, 2023 that it had filed for bankruptcy in a bid to negotiate down its debt. The coworking company said its bankruptcy impacts operations in the United States and Canada, but "global operations are expected to continue as usual." (Photo by Anthony WALLACE / AFP) (Photo by ANTHONY WALLACE/AFP via Getty Images) (AFP via Getty Images)
The current WeWork logo. (WeWork)

Aberdeen

Investment company Aberdeen went back to its original name after removing the vowels to become Abrdn in 2021. The rebranded name was hard to read and "widely mocked," according to the BBC, leading the firm to restore the vowels.

COWES, ENGLAND - AUGUST 06: Branding during Aberdeen Asset Management Cowes Week on August 6, 2016 in Cowes, England. (Photo by Alan Crowhurst/Getty Images) (Getty Images)
Aberdeen's rebrand to Abrdn did not stick, and it returned to this familiar look. (Getty Images)

Tropicana

In 2009, Tropicana launched a redesign of the packaging for its orange juice that eliminated the orange-and-straw image customers had embraced. The effort quickly soured its relationship with consumers, and the new design was scrapped in a matter of weeks.

SAN ANSELMO, CALIFORNIA - FEBRUARY 27: Containers of Tropicana orange juice are displayed on a grocery store shelf on February 27, 2025 in San Anselmo, California. Tropicana Brands Group, the maker of Tropicana orange juice, is facing a financial crisis due to shifting consumer trends and higher prices that could result in a bankruptcy filing. Orange production is also down in Florida, and this year's crop could be the lowest in 88 years after the region has been impacted recently with devastating hurricanes. (Photo by Justin Sullivan/Getty Images) (Getty Images)
Tropicana has kept this packaging after scrapping an attempt at a more streamlined look. (Getty Images)

IN THIS ARTICLE